| Apricot Bowl VI: 2010 Morrisville State Mustangs 8 |
 |
John DiGiovanni |
| Apricot Bowl V: 2009 Colby Mules 6 |
 |
Roy Andrews |
| Apricot Bowl IV: 2008 Florida A&M Rattlers 6 |
 |
Will Riney |
| Apricot Bowl III: 2007 William & Mary Tribe 7 |
 |
Shawn Jackson |
| Apricot Bowl II: 2006 Texas State Bobcats 6 |
 |
Choya Teichelman |
| Apricot Bowl I: 2005 Mount Union Purple Raiders 7 |
 |
Steve Dutko |
| Season | Omega Conference | Theta Conference | Sigma Conference |
| 2006 | Lawrence 4-2-0 | Texas State 4-1-1 | Mount Union 4-2-0 |
| 2007 | William & Mary 4-2-0 | Texas State 5-1-0 | Youngstown State 3-3-0 |
| 2008 | Florida A&M 5-1-0 | Texas State 4-2-0 | Dartmouth 5-1-0 |
| 2009 | Colby 5-1-0 | West Texas A&M 4-1-1 | Youngstown State 4-2-0 |
| 2010 | Morrisville State 4-1-1 | Appalachian State 6-0-0 | Princeton 5-1-0 |
| School | Coach | Years Played | Overall Record | Power Rating | Team Page | |
 | Catawba | Tim Kirby | 2009 | 4-3-3 | 1 | Indians Page |
 | Delta State | Chad Chancellor | 2008-2009 | 5-11-1 | -1 | Statemen Page |
 | Lawrence | Larry Musich | 2006-2009 | 18-20-4 | +1 | Vikings Page |
 | William & Mary | Shawn Jackson | 2005-2009 | 25-20-8 | +6 | Tribe Page |
| Rivalry Logo | Rivalry Summary | Rivalry Results | Seasons |
| Kean Cougars vs Princeton Tigers vs Virginia Union Panthers |
--- Series Tied 0-0-0 No One Holds Trophy | 2011-2012 |
| Colby Mules vs Morrisville State Mustangs |
--- Series Tied 0-0-0 No One Holds Trophy | 2011-2014 |
| Colby Mules vs Dartmouth Big Green |
Colby Series Tied 0-0-1 Dartmouth Currently Holds Musket | 2010-2013 |
| Texas State Bobcats vs West Texas A&M Buffaloes |
Texas State Wins Series 2-0-1 Texas State Owns Spur | 2008-2009 |
| Kean Cougars vs Mount Union Purple Raiders |
Mount Union Lead Series 2-1 Kean Currently Holds Trophy | 2009-2012 |
| Mount Union Purple Raiders vs Youngstown State Penguins |
Youngstown State Leads Series 3-0 Youngstown Currently Holds Buckeye | 2009-2012 |
| Dartmouth Big Green vs Princeton Tigers |
Princeton Leads Series 3-0 Princeton Currently Holds Belt | 2009-2012 |
| Appalachian State Mountaineers vs Delta State Statesmen |
Appalachian State Wins Series 3-0 Appalachian State Owns Trophy | 2008-2009 |
| Florida A&M Rattlers vs Humboldt State Lumberjacks |
Humboldt State Leads Series 1-0-1 Humboldt State Currently Holds Basket | 2009-2012 |