Picks Record
(All Games Picked) | W | L | T |
| Dartmouth |
| | |
| Morrisville State |
| | |
| Monmouth |
| | |
| Appalachian State |
| | |
| Old Dominion |
| | |
| Texas State |
| | |
| Mount Union |
| | |
| Virginia Union |
| | |
| Youngstown State |
| | |
| Humboldt State |
| | |
| Florida A&M |
| | |
| Colby |
| | |
| Kean |
| | |
| Princeton |
| | |
| Rhode Island |
| | |
| Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| | |
| Chadron State |
| | |
| Kutztown |
| | |
| West Texas A&M |
| | |
| Montana |
| | |
| Shaw |
| | |
|
Deuce Record
(2 Point Games) | W | L | T |
| Dartmouth |
| | |
| Morrisville State |
| | |
| Monmouth |
| | |
| Appalachian State |
| | |
| Old Dominion |
| | |
| Texas State |
| | |
| Mount Union |
| | |
| Virginia Union |
| | |
| Youngstown State |
| | |
| Humboldt State |
| | |
| Florida A&M |
| | |
| Colby |
| | |
| Kean |
| | |
| Princeton |
| | |
| Rhode Island |
| | |
| Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| | |
| Chadron State |
| | |
| Kutztown |
| | |
| West Texas A&M |
| | |
| Montana |
| | |
| Shaw |
| | |
|
Sure Thing Record
(Bonused Games) | W | L | T |
| Dartmouth |
| | |
| Morrisville State |
| | |
| Monmouth |
| | |
| Appalachian State |
| | |
| Old Dominion |
| | |
| Texas State |
| | |
| Mount Union |
| | |
| Virginia Union |
| | |
| Youngstown State |
| | |
| Humboldt State |
| | |
| Florida A&M |
| | |
| Colby |
| | |
| Kean |
| | |
| Princeton |
| | |
| Rhode Island |
| | |
| Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| | |
| Chadron State |
| | |
| Kutztown |
| | |
| West Texas A&M |
| | |
| Montana |
| | |
| Shaw |
| | |
|
Rebel Record
(1-3 teams w/ same pick) | W | L | T |
| Dartmouth |
| | |
| Morrisville State |
| | |
| Monmouth |
| | |
| Appalachian State |
| | |
| Old Dominion |
| | |
| Texas State |
| | |
| Mount Union |
| | |
| Virginia Union |
| | |
| Youngstown State |
| | |
| Humboldt State |
| | |
| Florida A&M |
| | |
| Colby |
| | |
| Kean |
| | |
| Princeton |
| | |
| Rhode Island |
| | |
| Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| | |
| Chadron State |
| | |
| Kutztown |
| | |
| West Texas A&M |
| | |
| Montana |
| | |
| Shaw |
| | |
|
Deans Record
(Picking Own Conference) | W | L | T |
| Youngstown State |
| | |
| Virginia Union |
| | |
| Florida A&M |
| | |
| Humboldt State |
| | |
| Colby |
| | |
| Princeton |
| | |
| Texas State |
| | |
| Morrisville State |
| | |
| Mount Union |
| | |
| Dartmouth |
| | |
| Kean |
| | |
| Appalachian State |
| | |
| Monmouth |
| | |
| Old Dominion |
| | |
| Rhode Island |
| | |
| Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| | |
| Chadron State |
| | |
| Kutztown |
| | |
| West Texas A&M |
| | |
| Montana |
| | |
| Shaw |
| | |
|
Tough Guy Record
(50-50 Split) | W | L | T |
| Dartmouth |
| | |
| Morrisville State |
| | |
| Monmouth |
| | |
| Appalachian State |
| | |
| Old Dominion |
| | |
| Texas State |
| | |
| Mount Union |
| | |
| Virginia Union |
| | |
| Youngstown State |
| | |
| Humboldt State |
| | |
| Florida A&M |
| | |
| Colby |
| | |
| Kean |
| | |
| Princeton |
| | |
| Rhode Island |
| | |
| Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| | |
| Chadron State |
| | |
| Kutztown |
| | |
| West Texas A&M |
| | |
| Montana |
| | |
| Shaw |
| | |
|