| Logo | Name of League Team (Coach) | W | L | % | Picks |
| Cyphers Academy Mudcats (Ron Cyphers)-x |
17 | 1 | .944 | 94-20 |
| DiCaprio College Friars (Stephen DiCaprio)-x |
16 | 2 | .889 | 93-29 |
| Sullivan State Wolfpack (Kevin Sullivan) |
15 | 3 | .833 | 91-25 |
| Miller State Maples (Greg Miller) |
14 | 4 | .778 | 83-29 |
| Perrotta State Stingrays (Ray Perrotta) |
11 | 7 | .611 | 81-26 |
| Krygier A&M Charioteers (John Krygier) |
11 | 7 | .611 | 84-36 |
| University of Riney Rhinos (Will Riney) |
8 | 10 | .444 | 76-42 |
| JJ Institute Sun Devils (Joe Tenpenny) |
7 | 11 | .389 | 78-33 |
| Bishop Community College Cardinals (Nate Bishop) |
7 | 11 | .389 | 76-40 |
| Syracuse State Eagles (Mike Scarcella) |
7 | 11 | .389 | 69-45 |
| Cone State Reefs (Jack Cone) |
6 | 12 | .333 | 73-40 |
| Dan University Orange Fitz (Dan Fitzmaurice) |
5 | 13 | .278 | 52-22 |
| DiGiovanni University-Bensonhurst Skulls
(John DiGiovanni) |
5 | 13 | .278 | 69-44 |
| St. Patrick On-Line U Virtual Warriors (Patrick Griffith) |
4 | 14 | .222 | 57-28 |
| Matt State Warthogs (Matt Davis) |
2 | 16 | .111 | 50-40 |
