| Total Sports Member | POTM Awards | Last Won |
| Roy Andrews | 8 | December, 2011 |
| Will Riney | 7 | August, 2010 |
| Frank Ward | 7 | December, 2009 |
| John Krygier | 7 | July, 2011 |
| Matt Davis | 5 | March, 2011 |
| Ron Cyphers | 5 | August, 2011 |
| Steve DiCaprio | 4 | February, 2012 |
| Shawn Jackson | 4 | July, 2008 |
| Nate Bishop | 3 | May, 2009 |
| Tony Macaluso | 2 | June, 2011 |
| Greg Miller | 2 | October, 2010 |
| John DiGiovanni | 2 | October, 2011 |
| Mark Walraven | 1 | October, 2009 |
| Andy Beirow | 1 | December, 2008 |
| RoseAnn Krygier | 1 | November, 2008 |
| Larry Musich | 1 | October, 2008 |
| Chad Chancellor | 1 | December, 2007 |
| Chris Webb | 1 | January, 2007 |
|
2006: January- NA February-NA March-NA April-NA May-NA June-NA July-NA August-MA September-NA October-NA November-NA December- Frank Ward(1) |
2007: January- Chris Webb(1) February- Ron Cyphers(1) March- Roy Andrews(1) April- Will Riney(1) May- Nate Bishop(1) June- Roy Andrews(2) July- Greg Miller(1) August- Roy Andrews(3) September- Will Riney(2) October- Shawn Jackson(1) November- Shawn Jackson(2) December- Chad Chancellor(1) |
2008: January- Frank Ward(2) February- Nate Bishop(2) March- Shawn Jackson(3) April- John Krygier(1) May- John DiGiovanni(1) June- Ron Cyphers(2) July- Shawn Jackson(4) August- Will Riney(3) September- Will Riney(4) October- Larry Musich(1) November- RoseAnn Krygier(1) December- Andy Beirow(1) | |
|
2009: January- Will Riney(5) February- Matt Davis(1) March- Tony Macaluso(1) April- Frank Ward(3) May- Nate Bishop(3) June- John Krygier(2) July- Frank Ward(4) August- Frank Ward(5) September- Roy Andrews(4) October- Mark Walraven(1) November- John Krygier(3) & Frank Ward(6) December- Frank Ward(7) |
2010: January- Roy Andrews(5) February- John Krygier(4) March- Matt Davis(2) April- Stephen DiCaprio(1) May- John Krygier(5) June- Will Riney(6) July- Ron Cyphers(3) August- Will Riney(7) September- Ron Cyphers(4) October- Greg Miller(2) November- John Krygier(6) December- Steve DiCaprio(2) |
2011: January-Matt Davis(3) February- Matt Davis(4) March- Matt Davis(5) April- Roy Andrews(6) May- Steve DiCaprio(3) June- Tony Macaluso(2) July- John Krygier(7) August- Will Riney(7) September- Ron Cyphers(5) October- John DiGiovanni(2) November- Roy Andrews(7) December- Roy Andrews(8) |
|
| 2012: January- Stephen DiCaprio(4) |